In California, being partly at fault for an accident does not automatically prevent you from seeking damages. Under the state’s pure comparative negligence rule, any damages available may be reduced by the percentage of responsibility assigned to you.
If an adjuster, another driver, or a police report suggests that you share blame, the facts of the accident can affect how the rule applies. This article explains how fault percentages may affect a claim, how responsibility is evaluated, what can happen when several parties are involved, and how the rule may apply across different case types under California law.
Key Takeaways
- California uses a pure comparative negligence rule. This means an injured person may still seek damages even if they share some, or most, of the responsibility for an accident, although any damages awarded are reduced by their percentage of fault.
- A court or jury first determines the total damages, then reduces that amount by the injured person’s share of fault. For example, a person found 30 percent responsible would receive 70 percent of the damages otherwise awarded.
- When more than one defendant may be responsible, California law treats financial losses and personal losses differently. Under Proposition 51, California Civil Code section 1431.2, a defendant may be responsible for all economic damages in some circumstances, while responsibility for noneconomic damages is generally limited to that defendant’s share of fault.
- Fault percentages may be resolved during negotiations, but an insurer’s early assessment is not a final legal finding. If a case goes to trial, a jury may decide each party’s share of responsibility under the applicable California jury instructions.
- Comparative fault can arise in many California negligence claims, including those involving commercial vehicles, construction accidents, bicycle and pedestrian accidents, unsafe property conditions, product liability, and wrongful death. Workers’ compensation is generally a no-fault system, though a separate claim against a third party may still involve comparative fault.
What Is Pure Comparative Negligence Under California Law?
Pure comparative negligence is California’s rule for handling accidents in which more than one person may share responsibility. Under California Civil Code section 1714, people generally have a duty to use reasonable care to avoid harming others. When someone may not have used reasonable care, comparative negligence allows responsibility to be divided among the parties, with each person assigned a percentage that adds up to 100 percent.
In California, “pure” means there is no percentage of fault that automatically prevents an injured person from seeking damages in a negligence claim. Instead, the person’s damages may be reduced by their own share of responsibility. The California Supreme Court adopted this approach in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. in 1975, replacing the older contributory negligence rule, which could bar recovery when an injured person had any fault at all.
For someone who has been told they share blame for an accident, the key point is that fault is not necessarily all or nothing under California law. The available evidence, the actions of everyone involved, and the damages claimed can all affect how responsibility is evaluated.
How Your Percentage of Fault Changes What You Can Recover
California negligence claims are all different, but they generally follow a similar path when it comes to determining fault. Damages are usually identified first, then reduced by the injured person’s percentage of fault. For example, if the evidence supports $100,000 in damages and the injured person is found 25 percent responsible, the amount remaining after the reduction would be $75,000.
The table below is an example of how California’s pure comparative negligence rule works. It is not an estimate of what any claim may be worth.
| Injured person’s assigned share of fault | Damages found | Reduction applied | Amount remaining |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | $100,000 | $10,000 | $90,000 |
| 25% | $100,000 | $25,000 | $75,000 |
| 50% | $100,000 | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| 75% | $100,000 | $75,000 | $25,000 |
| 99% | $100,000 | $99,000 | $1,000 |
Damages can include economic losses, such as medical expenses and lost earnings, as well as noneconomic losses, such as pain and suffering. The percentage of fault applies to the total damages found, though the analysis can become more involved when more than one defendant may be responsible.
How Fault Is Decided in a California Injury Claim
Fault percentages are often resolved through negotiations between the injured person’s attorney and the insurance company, rather than by a court. An insurance adjuster may assign an early percentage of fault, but that assessment is a negotiating position, not a legal finding. If the claim does not resolve and goes to trial, a jury may decide how responsibility is ultimately divided.
The evidence used to evaluate fault can include:
- Police reports or crash reports, which may document observations, statements, and other information gathered after the accident
- Photographs of the scene, vehicle damage, road conditions, or injuries
- Video from traffic cameras, nearby businesses, or other available sources
- Statements from people who saw the accident
- Medical records that may help show how the injury occurred and its effects
- Electronic data from commercial vehicles
- Physical evidence from the scene, such as vehicle damage or roadway markings
If a claim goes to trial, the jury may be instructed under California Civil Jury Instructions CACI 405 to consider whether the injured person’s own negligence contributed to the harm and to assign fault percentages accordingly. A police report may be useful evidence, but it reflects an officer’s observations and, in some cases, opinion. It generally does not bind the parties or the jury.
When More Than One Party Is at Fault: Proposition 51
When several defendants may be responsible for a personal injury claim in California, Proposition 51 treats economic and noneconomic damages differently. In most situations, each defendant is only responsible for noneconomic damages in proportion to that defendant’s share of fault. Defendants may still be jointly and severally liable for economic damages, which means one liable defendant may be responsible for the full economic loss.
In plain language:
- Joint and several liability for economic damages means that a liable defendant may be responsible for the full amount of losses such as medical expenses, lost earnings, and other financial harm, even if another responsible party cannot pay.
- Several liability for noneconomic damages means that each defendant is generally responsible only for that defendant’s percentage of losses such as pain and suffering.
For example, a commercial vehicle collision might involve a carrier, a company responsible for vehicle maintenance, and a contractor responsible for an unsafe roadway condition. If each party contributed to the accident, their roles and percentages of fault may be evaluated separately. The injured person’s own percentage of fault is also considered and may reduce the total damages before these allocation rules are applied.
Proposition 51 is especially important when a responsible party cannot pay its share. Another liable defendant may still be responsible for economic damages, while noneconomic damages are generally limited to each defendant’s own percentage of fault.
How Comparative Fault Applies Across California Injury Cases
California’s pure comparative negligence rule can apply across many types of personal injury and wrongful death claims. For example:
- Commercial trucking crashes: A carrier may argue that the other party’s speed, position on the road, or following distance contributed to the crash. Driver logs, electronic vehicle data, and applicable Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration regulations may also be relevant.
- Construction and worksite accidents: Responsibility may be disputed among a general contractor, subcontractors, equipment suppliers, property owners, and others involved in the worksite.
- Bicycle accidents: Insurers may raise issues involving lane position, lighting, visibility, or helmet use. Under California law, bicycle riders under 18 must wear a properly fitted and fastened helmet in the locations covered by Vehicle Code section 21212.
- Pedestrian accidents: Crossing location, signal timing, visibility, and the actions of drivers may all be examined.
- Wrongful death claims: If the person who died is found partly at fault, that percentage may reduce the damages available to surviving family members.
- Premises and product liability claims: A property owner may argue that a visitor’s actions contributed to an injury. In product liability matters, California courts have also applied comparative fault principles to strict product liability claims.
- Motor vehicle accidents: In more typical vehicle claims, the parties may dispute issues such as speed, right of way, following distance, or attention to traffic conditions.
How Insurers Raise Comparative Fault During a Claim
Comparative fault is often discussed early in a California personal injury claim because each percentage point assigned to the injured person can reduce the damages the insurer may owe. An adjuster may evaluate the accident, the available evidence, and the injured person’s own actions when deciding how to assess responsibility.
An insurer may:
- Request a recorded statement soon after the accident, before the injured person has a complete understanding of what happened or the extent of their injuries
- Ask questions about speed, attention, visibility, positioning, or other actions that may be relevant to fault
- Review public social media activity and, in some claims, conduct surveillance
- Examine gaps in medical treatment or delayed reporting and raise questions about the seriousness or cause of an injury
- Present an early settlement offer alongside an assessment of fault
An injured person’s obligations to their own insurer may differ from any obligation to provide information to another party’s insurer, depending on the policy and circumstances. Once retained, Coopers LLP’s personal injury lawyers can communicate with insurers on the client’s behalf, respond to requests for statements and records, review medical and employment documentation, and explain the available options at each stage.
What to Do If You Are Being Blamed for a California Accident
If you are being blamed for a California accident, a few practical steps can help you document what happened and keep relevant information available while the claim is open.
- Get medical care and follow through with recommended treatment. Medical records can help document injuries and treatment, while gaps in care may raise questions during a claim.
- Photograph the scene, vehicles or equipment, and visible injuries. Keep the original files and note the date they were taken.
- Identify witnesses and save their contact information. Witnesses can become difficult to reach as time passes.
- Request the police report or crash report. Review it for factual errors, such as the reported direction of travel, lane, or time of the accident.
- Preserve physical evidence. Keep damaged clothing, equipment, and other items, including a damaged bicycle, in their post-accident condition when possible.
- Note where video may exist. Nearby businesses, traffic cameras, and commercial vehicles may have relevant footage, and some systems retain recordings for only a limited time.
- Be deliberate about recorded statements and social media. Consider the purpose of a request from another party’s insurer before providing a recorded statement, and remember that public posts may be reviewed during a claim.
How Fault Disputes Affect Legal Deadlines
California personal injury deadlines continue to run while fault is being disputed. Under California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1, many personal injury lawsuits generally must be filed within two years of the accident. Claims involving a California public entity can have a much shorter notice requirement, often 6 months, under Government Code section 911.2. A California personal injury attorney can help determine what deadlines apply to your situation.
Talk With Coopers LLP About Fault in Your California Personal Injury Claim
An insurer’s fault assessment can shape a personal injury claim’s evaluation. It is not, however, the final word on what happened. A complete review may require looking at the available evidence, the actions of everyone involved, the losses documented in the record, and whether other parties may share responsibility.
If you are facing a comparative-fault allegation after a California accident, contact Coopers LLP today for a free consultation. We work exclusively on a contingency fee basis for injury cases. You pay no attorney fees or costs unless we recover compensation for you.
FAQs About Comparative Negligence in California
Can I still recover if I was more than 50 percent at fault in California?
Yes. California’s pure comparative negligence rule has no cutoff percentage, so a person who is more than 50 percent at fault may still pursue damages. However, compensation will be reduced by the injured person’s assigned share of fault. At very high percentages, the amount remaining may be small relative to the time and cost of pursuing a claim.
Who decides my percentage of fault in California?
In most claims, the percentage of fault is negotiated between the injured person’s attorney and the insurer. The insurer’s early percentage is a position, not a legal finding. If the claim goes to trial, a jury may decide fault under California Civil Jury Instructions CACI 405.
Does comparative fault apply to bicycle and pedestrian negligence claims?
Yes. Insurers may raise issues such as a cyclist’s lane position, lighting, visibility, or helmet use, or a pedestrian’s crossing location and signal timing. California requires bicycle helmets only for riders under 18 under Vehicle Code section 21212, though an insurer may still raise helmet use as an issue based on the facts of a claim.
Will being found partly at fault raise my California insurance rates?
It depends on the policy and the rating rules that apply to it. California regulates automobile insurance rating factors under Proposition 103, and a driver’s safety record is among those factors. Contact your insurer for an answer about a specific policy.
